ugh

not sure what but something kept me coming back to this image.

I can see why you like it, the soft accent of light on the bottle and contents. I think the DoF here is interesting, Over all though it has what I call "Thumbnail syndrome", thats where the photo looks interesting until you enlarge it, then it loses its appeal.

Love the detail of this chair...5th picture I know but I wasn't "in love" with any of my images.

I like this photo, good exposure, angle and composition, I would like to see all of the tacks on the top and center to be in focus, so you would have to close down a few stops to get them in. Its a great texture source and I can see you using this as a layer or background in a composite project or something. Love the silver tacks on the green texture.